I was a passenger on the EuroNight 60466 D. Budapest-Keleti at 2100 on 30 June 2015, scheduled arrival Zürich HB at 0820 on 1st July 2015. I was a passenger in the Sleeping Car on this service (there are three carriages from Budapest – a carriage with seats, a couchette car, and the sleeping car), and these are coupled with EN 466 from Wien Hbf west of Salzburg. No carriages on the service start outside the Schengen zone.
At 0700, 4 minutes after the arrival of the service at Buchs SG, the first station stop in Switzerland, and while the train was still stationary, Swiss police came through the train and demanded passports from all passengers in the carriage in which I was travelling. It’s not the first time I have been controlled here. The Policeman had already asked for passports from the two other passengers in the compartment, and then reached up towards me.
My conversation with the police officer went as follows (translated from German):
Jon to Policeman: Is this a customs control, or a border control?
J: Is this a customs or a border control?
P: Customs controlJ: Why then have you asked nothing about the luggage I have with me, and are just asking for passports?
P: Because I am from the Police
J: So it looks like a Border Control then?
(Policeman points to the logo on his blue shirt)
P: We are the Police here. It’s not the same.
And then I showed my passport, and the Policeman left. He did not even look at my bag, let alone examine anything in it.
The logo on the Policeman’s shirt was too small to read, but I assume he was from the Cantonal Police of the St Gallen Canton (in which Buchs is located).
So once more we are back with Article 21 of the Schengen Borders Code, and the four criteria:
(i) do not have border control as an objective,
(ii) are based on general police information and experience regarding possible threats to public security and aim, in particular, to combat cross-border crime,
(iii) are devised and executed in a manner clearly distinct from systematic checks on persons at the external borders,
(iv) are carried out on the basis of spot-checks;
So, despite this being described as a customs check (Zollkontrolle), it was not that as it concerned only my documents and not what I was carrying. That it was carried out by Police, and not by the Swiss border force, does not clearly distinguish it from a border control. No justification for the check was given. Plus, in conversation with regular travellers in the same carriage, they confirmed to me that these checks take place every time they cross this border on a night train.
This looks to me – yet again – like a pretty blatant breach of Schengen. I will, as with all previous cases, submit a complaint to the Commission, and will post the response here when I receive it.
You are my hero on this, Jon! The Swiss border controls (or whatever they want to call them) are among the most unpleasant ones I have encountered yet. I have also been checked at this very same station.
It is interesting to see how the border control differs from country to country. Up here in the north, the border guards are mainly interested in knowing if you are transporting illegal drugs, live animals or such things. The Swedish customs officials walk through some of the trains from Denmark and stand in the hallway at ferry terminals, sometimes accompanied by dogs sniffing for drugs. If you leave your luggage unattended while you go to the restaurant at the X 2000 trains from Copenhagen to Stockholm and Gothenburg, the customs officials will ask you about where your luggage is as the customs officials do not like unattended luggage. If it looks as if you are carrying too much alcohol off the ferry from Finland, then show them that you are not, and that’s it. No need to show any passport or any other kind of identity document. On the other hand, a Swiss customs official seems to pay zero interest in luggage and is only interested in seeing identity documents. Did you try using your German driving licence in Switzerland?
ein paar fakten:
1. eine personenkontrolle nach dem ersten halt in der schweiz ist nach schengenrecht jederzeit möglich. selbst direkt auf der grenze im rahmen eines grenzübertrittes möglich. siehe art 21 schengener grenzkodex
2. ein schweizer grenzwächter kann im rahmen einer zollkontrolle jederzeit, auch direkt am anfang, die ausweispapiere verlangen und kontrollieren ohne weiter gehenden zollkontrolle.
3. das anschauen eines ausweises, ohne überprüfung in den datenbanken ist keine personenkontrolle.
4. beim grenzübertritt muss jede person in besitz eines grenzübertritspapier sein. dies kann jederzeit auf der grenze kontrolliert werden.
Sorry, but I don’t actually give much care what the Swiss law is here. Switzerland has agreed to the rules of Schengen, and if the Swiss are not complying with that the EU has a problem.
On 1. – it was AT the first stop in Switzerland.
2. – it was not a “Grenzwächter” but the cantonal police, and why was the check announced as a customs control anyway?
3. – so if the officer chose to scan the paper, does he then have to ask me to do so, and justify it?
4. – yes, I know. I have had plenty of these sorts of controls in the past (I have documented more than half a dozen on this blog). I know I need my passport with me, but the question is under what circumstances this can be demanded to be shown.
In my case, very simple act of abuse. Traveling with my son (17 y/o) from italy asked if we spoke Italian. No.. where do you live, the US. Where are you coming from, he’s coming from Florence I’m coming from Israel. Where are you going, Zürich. By that time the had already approached close enough to show they were willing to engage in a potential arrest. Anything to declare, NO. No ah? No. Took one bag, they check it thoroughly but don’t let you see what they do, checked the second one, same. Took our passports and with special devices looking at both (passports from spain). You can sense he knows nothing will be found. But wants to take it further (typical European abuse reminding me of what happened with my family back in the 1940’s). Calls someone to check on each passport, provides numbers and clearly you know nothing to pursue. He stands there and thinks what else to do, ten minutes of abuse, knowing nothing to be found but then he said, you live in the US ah? Yes. Why. Because that’s where we live. Actually as you can see, my son was born there. Ah. Went to Israel ah? Yes. Why. Because I want to. I do it often. Ah.. throws passports on the floor, enjoy your time here and leaves. Last time I will spend a penny in this country. Keep it to your selves as your xenophobic genes do not allow you to belong to a diverse world. You are not diverse, your are not European, you are not Shengen, you are not Euro, your are not part of an integrated world society. I am very proud to be a financial individual who has taken away monies from customers who had it in your country and will continue doing it as your loundering empire faints and your cheap chocolate sells less and less. Generic medicines are your nightmare and your mountains are to be found in Canada with more friendly people.
TGV9240 Turin-Paris 09/05/2019. When we made the usual stop at Modane (crew change, etc) there was a passport/ID inspection. I’ve not experienced this before on this service, I guess it was just a (random?) spot-check.