What sort of Brexit did the British actually want? That’s actually a damned hard question to answer – because before 23rd June we did not have a concrete Brexit plan that the Brits were voting on. The Leave campaign remained vague and presented no single Brexit variant. The question on the ballot paper gives us no real help either:

laurenceevans1_2016-oct-11

It says Leave the European Union. Countries like Norway and Mongolia are not in the European Union, and they have very different relations with the European Union. Hence we cannot conclude from the question what variant of Brexit the British voted for. A Norway-style relationship with the EU would be a Brexit – because Norway is not in the EU. A Mongolia-style relationship likewise.

To put it another way, we cannot draw any solid conclusions – in any sort of way – about what variant of Brexit the Brits voted for, or what sort of relationship the UK should have with the EU after Brexit.

You can make a case for all sorts of relationships the UK should have with the EU, and they all have their various merits, but what you absolutely cannot do is draw solid conclusions about what that relationship should look like based on what happened before 23rd June. That – in the words of Jason O’Mahony – is refjacking (referendum-hijacking), or the process of attaching significance to something after the fact. And note here: I am most definitely not saying that Brexit means a Norway option, or something like it, either – because it doesn’t. We simply do not adequately know.

That of course does not stop Brexiteers trying to do just that – to justify what the UK-EU relationship ought to look like based on their own interpretation of the referendum – but dressed up as fact.

[tweet 785872735700455424 hide_thread=’true’]
[tweet 785872556398112768 hide_thread=’true’]
[tweet 785859513048072193 hide_thread=’true’]
[tweet 785875874499457024 hide_thread=’true’]
[tweet 785876055261347840 hide_thread=’true’]
[tweet 785877754982068226 hide_thread=’true’]
[tweet 785881799838797826 hide_thread=’true’]
[tweet 785861248055447552 hide_thread=’true’]

And then an opinion piece from Norman Lamont FTW!

[tweet 785878094007730176 hide_thread=’true’]
[tweet 785881710403657728 hide_thread=’true’]
[tweet 785882424278474752 hide_thread=’true’]
[tweet 785886482296897536 hide_thread=’true’]

(note: not all tweets in the thread included – for brevity!)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.